domingo, janeiro 29, 2006

The Future of an Illusion by Sigmund Freud


“…all the gods of antiquity have been condensed. The people which first succeeded in thus concentrating the divine attributes was not a little proud of the advance. It had laid open to view the father who had all along been hidden behind every divine figure as its nucleus. Fundamentally this was a return to the historical beginnings of the idea of God. Now that God was a single person, man’s relations to him could recover the intimacy and intensity of the child’s relation to his father. But if one had done so much for one’s father, one wanted to have a reward, or at least to be his only beloved child, his Chosen People. Very much later, pious America laid claim to being ‘God’s own Country’; and, as regards one of the shapes in which men worship the deity, the claim is undoubtedly valid.”

The idea of a small group being labeled God’s Chosen People has always weirded me out …
(just as the phrase ‘weirded me out’ weirds me out).

Does God play favorites? Regardless, it seems everybody just wants to be daddy’s favorite.

4 Comments:

Blogger Esteban said...

We must be careful not to take Tertullian's train of thought further than his use and illustration constitutes. For instance, I don’t think we would want to say:

‘God is good therefore he is evil, or God is Love therefore he is hate’

or maybe we do…

I am worried about the world wide mentality that in our minds, we are the center of the universe. We are the person God wants, and we seem to take it even further at times and say ‘you are not chosen, I am chosen, you are wrong, I am right.’

The God of the Jews was okay with throwing millions of people into hellfire, or it seems so. They were Chosen. Or did they choose themselves?

I do not presume that I know what is fair and just better than God…although he is after all the one that gave us those morals and values of Love…

12:50 PM  
Blogger Esteban said...

'if we believe we are in fact 'chosen' (what ever that means), maybe instead of engaging in the 'im right, youre wrong' mentality, we humble oursevles'

but thats my problem, i can not bring myself to think 'i am chosen'

though i do think often 'oh crap, im probably not chosen' or 'i cant bring myslef to utilize being chosen, due to sympathy for the inumearble people that arent chosen'

10:04 AM  
Blogger Esteban said...

well put

hope keeps me sane

im jumping the gun

2:21 PM  
Anonymous Anônimo said...

In religion and politics, people's beliefs and convictions are in almost every case gotten at second hand, and without examination.
- Mark Twain

12:11 PM  

Postar um comentário

<< Home